Monday, July 23, 2012

Being On The Other Side

Have you ever read unpacking the invisible knapsack by Peggy Mcintosh? If you have not then I would suggest that you Google it. It is a quick and important read and is of the same theme that I am about to attempt to communicate.


I have now been in Costa Rica for 39 days. The first two weeks were easy. When you are surrounded by gringos, have a private bus that carts you around, and a guide that translates everything you could possibly need… Who needs to know Spanish?  There is an easy Answer- no one. It is very much like the United States in that I am able to go anywhere in my country and I am confident that someone could help me to have my needs met. I would never think twice about the fact that I only speak English, and while at times I might notice Spanish I would not feel completely inconvenienced or at a disadvantage for not knowing it. While studying at UPEACE for two weeks I must admit that I felt pretty good when I understood a bit of Spanish. After all, not much was presented to me so I felt pretty good about the amount that was coming my way! How hard could it be to learn more?

Well- As it turns out, it is much harder than I would have thought. My second two weeks here involved a school where if you wanted something from the administration you must first attempt to ask for it in Spanish. It was not uncommon to ask someone that did not speak English, and therefore if you failed you were out of luck until you found someone else. I lived with a family that spoke little to no English. I became a master at smiling and nodding. Hand gestures become much more useful, and not just something that the Italians do. I found that 30% of what I understood was due to my vocabulary, 10% was due to gestures and 60% was common sense from the context of the conversation. This is only of what I understood…. Which- was about 15% of what was presented to me. I continued to learn. We had small classes and in my second week I added private lessons where I had a great tutor. He challenged me more than I would have asked for or thought reasonable to be honest. It is one thing to feel stupid while discussing a topic of which you know nothing. Entirely different to feel ignorant while discussing a topic you have spent years studying. He asked me to discuss with him the similarities and differences between psychology and speech therapy. While I have much to say on this topic- I simply do not have the vocabulary or grammar to do it in Spanish!!

I tried though. Imagine my frustration at being the student that I am in the states; With my grades and my arrogance and my weaseling of the system- and then to be asked a simple question and not being able to say 5 sentences on the matter? It was horrifying. We worked through it. And afterwards he continued to challenge me. You don’t know how many times I growled and said “I don’t have the words” or “I can’t say it” How many times I wanted to assure someone that I actually am a semi-intelligent person. I have even expressed that in the Spanish world I am not that smart.

Now at my new school I am again living in a home where I do not speak English. We travel more here and there is constant threat of being ripped off by a taxi driver. In addition I have had to look up common things that I might WANT to say to a taxi driver when I think he is pulling my leg. Things I would never have to worry about in the states pop up here all the time. In Spanish I can ask for directions easily… Do you think this means I will understand the answer I receive? It absolutely does not. In Spanish I can usually tell someone what I need or want. Will I understand their response? No. Can I say most things that I want to? Yeah! But can I say them in the shortest, most grammatically correct way possible? Heck No- and I mess up all the time.

It is VERY interesting being on the other side of a language barrier. If I thought I had patience for foreign students before this I was wrong. To even think one time that I wished someone could speak faster so that I could leave or so that I could just help them and move on was a regretful thought on my part, and it probably did not only happen once. While I have admired the patience in others while they help I never felt TOO guilty about not having the patience myself- until now. I remember being at a peace conference in Ohio with Barbara and meeting an important woman from Egypt. She was very quiet and we thought she was timid or simply a typical Middle East woman. WRONG. Give a woman a translator and suddenly she is the most amazing person you have ever had the privilege of listening to as she screams outrage at the world.

Many times here I am afraid to try to speak Spanish because I know I am not very good. Many times here I doubt that what I have said is correct. I often wonder if people are making fun of me, and I fear that I will not be able to understand responses. Sometimes I let others speak for me because it is easier, and I almost always regret this. I found a place here that I would like to work. I asked what the requirements were and the first response was, “Are you bilingual?” Damn. Next comment, “Well you’re beautiful and that is half the qualification” HAHA. If only it were the CORRECT half. I am beautiful and yet someone who is ugly, with less specialized education, and with a worse personality would be 100 times more qualified. Therefore, it is not half the battle after all.

I now feel at a disadvantage. If I wanted to go to the hospital on my own I cannot. If I wanted to go to the mall on my own I would not readily know which bus to take. God forbid I ever take a wrong bus I will not easily be able to ask directions for the correct bus. I am constantly in danger of being taken advantage of or lied to. I cannot easily read nutrition information and I cannot read the news without a dictionary. Often I have to ask people to translate certain things and even when I think I know something on my own I could easily be wrong.

The conversation instructor that I had spoken of was incredibly patient. I have gained friends here that have put in great effort. People have extended a hand and helped me in places that I did not expect and I could not be more grateful. While I thought I was aware before I have found that I was not, and I know that I still have much to learn. I hope that in the future I always have this memory of being on the wrong side. As well as that when I meet others in my position; that I can respond in a manner which does not make them feel that they are on the wrong side- but rather a different side.

This is an experience that I would never give up.